Bridging the Divide
By MATT HILBURN, Associate Editor
A crucial tactic in the war on terrorism is being
developed at a nondescript, temporary office in a dusty corner
of Marine Corps Base Quantico, Va. A small education center here
will lead the way toward the creation of Marine expeditionary forces
much more adroit at dealing with the populations native to the
areas where Marines will be deployed in the future.
Officially opened Oct. 1, the Center for Advanced
Operational Culture Learning (CAOCL) has a straightforward task:
make Marines familiar with the language, customs and mores of the
populations they are likely to encounter.
In terms of battlefield prowess, senior Marines
consider this step at least as important as the development of
new hardware. Lt. Gen. James Mattis, commander of the Marine Corps
Combat Development Command, said, “Our Marines must be comfortable
operating in austere, very complex environments including those
where firepower is not the primary means to victory, or may even
be counterproductive.”
Marines steeped in the lessons learned from the
Iraq and Afghanistan conflicts agree that cultural awareness is
an important asset in the kinds of wars being fought in the post-Soviet
era.
Staff Sgt. Simon Lemay, a two-tour veteran of
Operation Iraqi Freedom temporarily assigned to the center, said, “Now
we’re understanding that culture is important to our kinetic
war all over the world. Our job is to better educate Marines right
here, right now so that we don’t have the problem we had
in Iraq with not understanding the people and not understanding
the culture; so we’re not offending people and making more
enemies.”
The new emphasis on cultural awareness is symptomatic
of a fundamental change within the service. Gen. Michael Hagee,
commandant of the Marine Corps, said in an April All Marine Message: “We
will place renewed emphasis on our greatest asset — the individual
Marine — through improved training and education in foreign
languages, cultural awareness, tactical intelligence and urban
operations.”
In recent months, the Marine Corps has doubled
the number of officers enrolled in the Defense Language Institute,
Monterey, Calif., and is assessing the purpose and assignments
of its foreign area officers, who are specialists in the language,
culture and political life of a geographic region. CAOCL, a part
of the Marine Corps Training and Education Command, was founded
to take a broad-brush approach to the education of Marine officers
and enlisted men and women.
Dr. Barak Salmoni, the deputy director of CAOCL
and a former program director in tactical culture at the Naval
Postgraduate School, said that from November 2004 onward there
was an understanding at every level, from the commanding general
of the division down to company commanders, that understanding
the basic components of the Iraqi experiences that make Iraqis
conduct themselves in certain ways toward each other and toward
Americans was essential in a stability and support operation.
In Iraq, for example, 95 percent of the Marines’ intelligence
about insurgent activities comes from the Iraqi people. Therefore,
it is critical to foster goodwill among Iraqis or local populations
wherever Marines might deploy, Mattis said.
During one of his tours in Iraq, Lemay was involved
in training Iraqi Security Forces where he encountered a potentially
tense situation that would have been impossible to imagine for
most Americans.
“I was never made aware of how unhappy an
Iraqi man would be if you stand or sit behind him,” he said. “As
I was in a group discussion, I walked up behind one of the Iraqis,
and he was very upset. He made it abundantly clear that I was not
to stand behind him.”
Lemay did some research and found that since Iraqi
culture has been so violent for decades, someone approaching from
behind could often be interpreted as a prelude to an execution.
“I teach those things to Marines, and they
pay attention,” he said.
Prior to CAOCL’s founding, the bulk of operational
culture and language training was the responsibility of the operating
forces, usually during predeployment training. The burden was often
too much to bear, and results were decidedly mixed.
“At the same time you’re getting up-armored
Humvees, you have to think about, conceptualize, source and provide,
and, in some cases, evaluate what kind of culture training you’ve
got,” Salmoni said. “It sometimes boiled down to a
battalion commander giving a phone call to someone he happened
to know, or met at a meeting. There was a lot of hitting the target
and a lot of missing the target. The burden is tremendous.”
As the Marine Corps culled through lessons learned,
it was clear there needed to be a center for operational cultural
training to develop concepts, products, source the training, plan
a realistic way of providing training, and find and vet assets
outside of the Marine Corps.
CAOCL serves both as a clearinghouse of cultural
information and a curriculum development center units from around
the Corps can lean on. Whether it be, for example, a report on
Ramadan prepared for an officer invited to “break fast” with
Iraqis, primers on the importance of family structure in Iraq or
MP3 audio files of basic Arabic streaming off its website, the
center aims to provide Marines easy access to the Corps’ ever-growing
base of knowledge.
The center works closely with units and teams
gearing up for deployment to develop tailor-made, operationally
relevant training modules that account for unit function and area
of deployment. CAOCL holds debriefings with units returning from
deployment. That feedback is then cycled back into the training
in the hopes of further refining it to suit Marines’ needs.
CAOCL also provides ongoing support for the Foreign Military Training
Unit.
“We did culture learning before we went
over for the war,” said Col. Jeff Bearor, the center’s
director. “It just wasn’t a lot of it. We may not have
thought it out as well as we needed to. It might have been good
for what it was, but it didn’t go in depth enough.”
According to Lemay, early training consisted of
basic greetings, a bit about Islam, some Iraqi history and learning
not to use your left hand or show the soles of your feet.
Although CAOCL has not been around for long, its
website (www.tecom.usmc.mil/caocl) hints at what the center eventually
will become and what it will offer Marines. While it’s very
Iraq-centric, the resources available span the entire globe.
Currently, the center offers the bare bones linguistic
familiarization in Iraqi Arabic, African French and Dari, with
Kurdish and Pashto in the works. For career Marines, the center
offers higher-level language learning opportunities in specific
regions of expertise. For heritage speakers and Marine linguists,
materials are available for Arabic, Russian, French, Spanish, Turkish
and Uzbek.
There are also reports available on crowd control,
transcripts from post-deployment debriefs, suggested readings and
even an article entitled “Marines Are From Mars, Iraqis Are
From Venus.”
CAOCL’s funding is fairly meager in the
grand scheme of military spending; $1.2 million was spent in the
latter half of fiscal year 2005, with $3.4 million earmarked for
this year. Bearor said the current staff is seven, but he expects
that to grow to 15-20 in the future.
In addition to the center’s permanent staff,
it draws expertise from Foreign Area Officers, Marine Corps Intelligence
Activity, civil service experts, contractors and the input of recently
deployed Marines such as Lemay.
Bearor said Hagee, who made a visit to the center
in late October, has set high goals for it. The first priority
is to continue to support the operating forces.
“This is predeployment training in particular.
We do this at home station through a series of instructional periods.
We train everybody from the MEF (Marine Expeditionary Force) staff
down to individual squads and platoons,” he said. “Obviously
the training is sculpted. Some of this is pretty straightforward:
the memorization of certain phrases in Arabic. Some of it is at
a higher level on how to incorporate culture into planning and
executing operations.”
According to Bearor, the center helps supervise
the predeployment training package at Marine Corps Air Ground Combat
Center Twentynine Palms, Calif., a 30-day program, a third of which
centers on urban warfare and stability and support operations training.
“That’s supported by role players
who accurately depict what’s going on on the streets of Iraq,” he
said. “We do that with a mix of contractors and Marines.”
Bearor said the center also is going to be engaged
in the mission rehearsal exercise that the Marine Air-Ground Task
Force staff training program was to conduct in December with I
MEF at Camp Pendleton, Calif., giving that training program a “culture
plug.”
The second priority for the center is to get operational
cultural and language training into the Marine Corps’ schoolhouses.
“We’re providing oversight and input
to the training program at The Basic School, Expeditionary Warfare
School, and Command and Staff College,” Bearor said. “Next
up are the Staff NCO (noncommissioned officer) academies. That
will occur sometime early next year.”
Providing regionally focused, distance learning
training for career Marines, will follow after that.
“The way we’re going to do that is
basically sergeants and lieutenants will get what we call the ‘Culture
101’ course,” Bearor said. “Basically [it’s]
the bedrock course to help inculcate a Marine on how to use culture
to their advantage instead of having it as a disadvantage. Every
career Marine is going to study some small region of the world.
We hope to get that going toward the end of the third quarter or
early fourth quarter next year.”
The final goal of the center is to give Marines
more and better language familiarization.
“We’re not going to turn them into
language professionals,” Bearor said. “That’s
DLI’s (Defense Language Institute’s) job, but we want
to ensure the maximum number of Marines possible, in particular
those Marines in the operating forces who are about to deploy someplace,
have at least some understanding or familiarization with the language
that they’re going to be operating in.”
For instance, for those Marines going to Iraq
now, the center helps provide several levels of language training.
The first is in the predeployment training package. It’s
rote memorization from a card. They’re given, for example, “the
seven phrases you’ll need to run a checkpoint.”
That initial, bare-bones familiarity is backed
up by CD sets that expand on the capability to tune Marines’ ears
to what they’ll hear on the street.
Bearor said it should allow Marines to be able
to distinguish between normal background noise on the street and
those situations where a Marine can key in on something important
and then enlist the help of a translator.
In the future, CAOCL may take advantage of II
MEF’s success with a program it calls the “survival
Arabic course.”
“It’s about 20 days of training, about
160 hours, that they provided to well over 2,000 Marines,” Bearor
said. “That’s about an intermediate level with the
goal of having one to three members of every platoon having some
increased level of language learning. At some point, we’ll
take that over and incorporate that into our products.”
If all goes well, operational culture and language
learning will be an integral part of professional military education.
“It will not be an exotic thing. It will
not be an added consideration. It will be mainstream,” said
Salmoni.
While the benefits of language ability — no
matter how basic — are fairly self evident, the advantages
of operational cultural understanding are perhaps more difficult
to grasp.
Bearor offers an example: “Americans tend
to be results oriented,” he said. “Here’s the
problem, detail the problem, come up with a plan, and fix the problem.
Iraqis, on the other hand, want to sit down and get to know you
first. If you just try to run over them in typical American fashion,
you’re going to have some problems.”
Personal relationships are so vital, a source
close to the Marine Corps said, the service is considering extending
the tours of Marine Civil Affairs Groups and Marines involved in
training Iraq Security Forces from seven to 12 months.